Crypto Execs in the Hot Seat at US House Committee Meetings on Defi and Web3. The positive response to the meetup was largely self-explanatory, and the industry appeared ready for a busy year.
Follow up
At a hearing on digital assets, top executives of six of the world’s largest crypto companies met with the Financial Services Committee of the United States House of Representatives. Although the tone was very proclamatory, the industry responded with optimism. It seems that crypto will be a popular topic on Capitol Hill for many years.
Mainstream media also paid attention to the Congress meeting. It is notable that this hearing marks the first time that senior industry leaders (aka “crypto moguls”) have directly expressed their fears and hopes for the $2.2-trillion sector of the economy to U.S. lawmakers.
Among the industry representatives called to the hearing were Jeremy Allaire (CEO of Circle); Sam Bankman-Fried (CEO of FTX); Chad Cascarilla (CEO of Paxos); Denelle Dixon (CEO of Stellar Development Foundation); Brian Brooks (CEO of Bitfury); and Alesia Haas, Chief Financial Officer of Coinbase.
this is the first positive public hearing on crypto that I can remember
congress seems to have done their homework, industry seems prepared and synchronized
still not sure what stellar is doing there
very bullish – could be the start of a trend
— Vance Spencer (@pythianism) December 8, 2021
Some of the key legislators who actively engaged with the crypto industry captains were Representative Pete Sessions, a Republican from Texas; Rep. Maxine Waters, a Democrat from California; Rep. Gregory Meeks, a Democrat from New York; Rep. Brad Sherman, a Democrat from California; Rep. Patrick McHenry, a Republican from North Carolina; Rep. Blaine Luetkemeyer, a Republican from Missouri; and Senator Sherrod Brown, a Democrat from Ohio.
So, here’s how it went down on the big day.
Key arguments
Allaire supported this point with an example from his firm’s operations: “Just in the past several weeks, Circle has signed on institutional customers who are using these services for small-business payments, international remittances and efficient payments for remote workers.” As he optimistically stated, soon “Dollars on the internet will be as efficient and widely available as text messages and email.”
Brooks took the message even closer to key political tensions of the day as he emphasized the opposition between tech behemoths such as Meta (formally Facebook) and the decentralizing impulse of crypto:
At the center of the CEOs’ narrative was the humanitarian significance of digital assets and their developmental potential. Cascarilla framed crypto as a “really powerful tool for democratization of access.”
The point of crypto is to have true decentralization, and the projects that succeed will be the projects that achieve that. Bitcoin succeeded because there were literally millions of participants in the node network, and so there is no CEO of Twitter to deplatform you, there’s no CEO of JPMorgan to take away your credit card.
It was also Brooks who laid out the powerful promise of the blockchain-powered Web3 era.
Aside from the fiery rhetoric, the message from the industry leaders was crisp and straightforward: It’s about time to bilaterally reconsider the rules of the game and put an end to the government’s suspicious paternalism. The industry is still being overseen by several federal agencies, state-by-state regulation is a mess, and the Securities and Exchange Commission is trying to hold its grip, characterizing digital assets as securities.
Well #crypto community… engagement in Washington is working! I think it’s clear from today’s hearing that we’ve turned a corner. Keep building. We’ll keep educating. #wagmi
— Kristin Smith (@KMSmithDC) December 8, 2021
The last point was clearly emphasized as the main problem: Coinbase’s Haas proposed deeming blockchain-based tokens as digital property or a way to record ownership, which would put them outside of the SEC’s jurisdiction.
Brooks didn’t spare words when highlighting the dysfunctional patterns of the current situation: “What happens in the United States is you have a new crypto project, and you walk into the SEC, and you describe it in great detail, and you ask for guidance, and they say, ‘We can’t tell you’ and ‘You list it at your own peril.’”
I’m surprised that after the congress hearings we didn’t get a pump! Today was a big day for crypto in the US! The hearings were super constructive and the senators were extremely positive! Incredible
— Ran NeuNer (@cryptomanran) December 8, 2021
Political divisions
The Dec. 8 hearing once again brought out a division regarding crypto-related issues that exists along party lines. Democrats focused their attention on investor protection and volatility, framing the industry as a potential threat to both uninformed investors and the global economy (environmental concerns were also mentioned.)
“Currently, cryptocurrency markets have no overarching or centralized regulatory framework, leaving investments in the digital assets space vulnerable to fraud, manipulation and abuse,” as Waters, who chairs the Financial Services Committee, put it.
Related: Lines in the sand: US Congress is bringing partisan politics to crypto
Sherman, one of the industry’s most consistent critics, expressed this anxiety in a quite vague, if not cryptic, form: “The powers in our society on Wall Street and in Washington have spent millions, and are trying to make billions or trillions, in the crypto world.”
Republican legislators, who — following a decades-old pattern of the American electoral system — are projected to win the majority in Congress in the next midterm elections, demonstrated a pragmatic approach.
My hope is that Congress will work with the digital asset market in its infancy to help Americans prosper and progress us forward as leaders on the world stage.//t.co/m6iKPql03Q
— Pete Sessions (@PeteSessions) December 11, 2021
In the words of McHenry, who is poised to chair the Financial Services Committee if the GOP wins back the House:
This technology is already regulated. Now, the regulations may be clunky, they may not be up to date. I ask my friends, my policymaker friends here on the Hill, this question: Do you know enough about this technology to have a serious debate?
Sessions went even further and gave an outright cheer to the industry, uttering a promise to support it: “I am tremendously impressed that from what I see, a lot of the ingenuity, a lot of entrepreneurial spirit, and lots of advice about the future, about where this can grow, is, I think, very important for us to listen to.”
Industry response
Despite certain disagreements between legislators, the hearing sparked a largely positive reaction from the crypto community, with Jake Chervinsky, head of policy at the Blockchain Association, calling it “the most positive, constructive, & bipartisan public event on crypto I’ve seen in Congress” and other experts largely projecting similar vibes.
Today’s HFSC hearing was the most positive, constructive, & bipartisan public event on crypto I’ve seen in Congress — ever. I mean that literally.
It’s a testament to the effectiveness of industry & community engagement in DC in recent months. We’ve made shockingly big progress.
— Jake Chervinsky (,) (@jchervinsky) December 8, 2021
Some representatives also projected an empathic epigraph in the aftermath of the hearing. Perhaps the most eloquent reaction belongs to Meeks, who demonstrated a moderate optimism toward the industry’s future:
The future of innovation in the financial markets is inevitable.
The use of digital assets can help underserved communities access additional financial tools – but we must make sure there is global coordination around regulation. pic.twitter.com/2DbvTZKMvp
— Rep. Gregory Meeks (@RepGregoryMeeks) December 8, 2021
The silence of crypto critic Sherman, normally an active Twitter user, was also notable.
What’s next
The overall optimistic mood of the hearing stands in contrast to some of the recent regulatory actions taken by the U.S. government. For one, the SEC denied WisdomTree’s application for a spot Bitcoin exchange-traded fund after seven months of consideration, keeping it impossible to invest in a regulated financial product providing direct exposure to the world’s oldest cryptocurrency.
Surely, the hearing will not be the last turn in the crypto-government conversation, even for 2021. Already, a hearing on stablecoins took place before the Senate Banking, Housing and Urban Affairs Committee on Dec. 14.
As Representative McHenry put it, “Congress must work to fully understand and embrace these innovative new technologies, like #crypto.” It looks like everyone should brace for a busy 2022 in crypto policy and regulation.
